Don't get me wrong - I like this beer enough and am confident enough that I decided to enter it into a homebrew competition. This particular comp was the first of its kind at Gordon's Wine and Liquor in Waltham, and it went off pretty well. There were 26 official entries, with a few extra thrown in at the last minute (I think 30 in total), and it took place in their rather classy "Culinary Center" located in the back of the store.
I had the "honor" of going first, as the staff poured my beer first to the three judges (a mixture of industry professionals, including one each from breweries Harpoon and Clown Shoes, and a third from a distributor that I cannot recall) and then to the rest of the crowd (Between 30 and 40 people). It seemed to go over well, and the judges suggested three areas for improvement - a creamier body, and a little more hop bitterness. The third judge (Ray, the distributor) mentioned that the brewer (me) must love strawberry-banana smoothies (exactly how I describe the beer to friends), because that's what he tasted.
As to those comments, I respect the opinions, but I also understand that they were coming from a place of personal preference. After the competition, all of the judges were complimentary of the beer and didn't seem shocked when it won second place overall (oh yeah, I won second place. I'll take it!). So with all due respect, I think I'll keep the recipe the way it is now.
After my beer, the competition went well and was a ton of fun. Some highlights included the winner (a double IPA with only summit hops), and a dry stout that wowed the judges, myself, and everyone sitting next to me (somehow this didn't place in the top three). The event also featured an incredible Tripel, and a couple of tasty Imperial Stouts as well that all could have justifiably beaten my beer.
But not all was honky dory - as one of the late entrants had a few surprises in for us. The brewer - clad in bike shorts, a tight t-shirt, and green plastic eyeglasses (to be fair he did ride his bike there) - introduced his beer by saying "If you really like tart cherries, then you'll like this beer. If you don't, then you're wrong." It was a tongue-in-cheek comment to be sure, but at the same time it points to the lunacy of the situation to unfold. The beer looked fine, even had a nice oud bruin brown color to it. However, as soon as I put my nose to it I had to take a step back. I asked the brewer what style it was, and he answered: "Whatever style uses 12 different strains of yeast." OK. That explained a lot actually.
The damn thing smelled like my kitchen, the part close to the cat box, right after my cat has a big meal. It tasted alright, with a funky and well-balanced sweetness to counteract the sour, but damn it smelled like cat-shit.
Then, the same wacky brewer had a beer called "sour time." Along the same lines of the first, this was a wild wild wild brew, and this one was beyond redeemable. Not only did it smell and taste awful (Bleach and metal cleaner come to mind), but it looked hideous with a slightly yellow head on top of a sickly tinted amber liquid. This was the last beer of the competition, and three hours later I can still taste it.
So overall, it was a great experience, and as a reward for second prize I won a pound of hops. However, considering I had to essentially drink toilet cleaner at the end of the night, I'm not sure it was worth it.
For those interested, I've posted the recipe below. If anybody has any ideas what hops I should get with my prize, let me know.
| 1.00 lb | Rice Hulls (0.0 SRM) | Adjunct | 9.52 % | |||||||
| 5.00 lb | Pale Malt (2 Row) US (2.0 SRM) | Grain | 47.62 % | |||||||
| 4.50 lb | Wheat Malt, Ger (2.0 SRM) | Grain | 42.86 % | |||||||
| 1.00 oz | Hallertauer [4.80 %] (60 min) | Hops | 17.6 IBU | |||||||
| 1 Pkgs | Weihenstephan Weizen (Wyeast Labs #3068) | Yeast-Wheat |










